As I mentioned in a recent post, I have been swapping out some problematic pantry products for better ones. One that I am really happy with is the seasoning I switched out for Old Bay.
Old Bay has been used in our family kitchens since before I was even born. It was such a staple in my mother's pantry that I would describe some things as being "Old Bay yellow" because the yellow and red tin can was so familiar. (By the way, Old Bay has a fascinating origin. It is old enough for my grandma to have taught Mama to use.)
The Big Switch
Recently, I learned that Old Bay had been bought out by McCormick (as they own something like 75% or 80-somet% of the spice market 🙄) and that it also contains sulfites that can stress my organs. So, yeah, it had to go.
What I found to replace the Old Bay is from Dan-O's SEA-soning line. It's the "Seafood Sea-soning" (like their wordplay) and it's so good.
![]() |
| From Amazon |
Also, for a 1/4 teaspoon serving, it has 50mg of sodium compared to Old Bay's 140mg. That is a huge difference.
![]() |
| Old Bay on right Dan-O on left |
Right away I could tell there was a difference this and Old Bay. For one thing, paprika and sea salt are dominant in the Dan-O's where Old Bay's salt kick comes from celery salt which is the first ingredient. I love celery salt in general, but it really overrides everything else in the flavor profile and, of course, there's the sodium... And, by the way, Old Bay is just as spicy to me if I taste it straight. Who knew? I didn't until now!
Another thing I noticed is that the Dan-O's already has the garlic and onion I always add when I use Old Bay. (Actually, I add garlic to almost everything.) The whole flavor profile reminds me a little of the original Mrs. Dash from back in the day - if Mrs. Dash had had more flavor. Remember how bland that stuff was? All those herbs in there and all I ever tasted was... that I needed salt!
Dan-O's and Old Bay look a lot alike, but the taste difference - and salt content - is the realist! The Dan's is more coarse.
![]() |
| Dan-O's is coarser |
I'm really happy to have found an even better replacement for an old family favorite. The price is good too and the jar is large enough that I won't have to replace it often. I wish it came in the bulk size that I used to buy Old Bay in, then just refill the tin every twice a year or so.
Some random thoughts
I have learned a quite a bit in looking for better products to swap out for ones I have always used. The For one thing, I look for those made by brands that are still privately owned. Once a giant buys a brand, everything becomes about money and if quality stands in the way, oh well. Another thing is "USDA Certified Organic" is different from the generic label of "Organic". Also, I watch for added sugar. It's surprising what you can find sweeteners added to.
The most import things are: Ingredients matter. Transparency matters. That's not always cheap, but the better a product is, usually the less of it you need to use. Fillers and unnecessary additives are a waste and could be hazardous to my health in the long run.
Peace
--Free
DISCLAIMERS:
I am not posting this as an "influencer". I have not/will not be compensated in any way for any item mentioned in this post. Nothing here is sponsored or incentivized in any way other than blog views. The items I post about was either paid for by me with my own money or gifted to me by friends or family using their own money. Experiences with the products are my own - not to influence anyone - and just to share my viewpoint. If I ever do post about/review something that I for which I received any compensation, I will post that clearly.






























